CSCUpdated May 19, 2026
Chicago Sinai Congregation
Annual Budget
FY 2026 / 2027
Finance Committee Recommendation
to the Chicago Sinai Congregation Board of Trustees
Board Presentation · April 14, 2026 · Final Approval: May 19, 2026
Budget Timeline & Finance Committee
Updated May 19, 2026
Approval Timeline
1
Mar 12 & 26
First-Pass Review
All budget categories reviewed
2
Early April
Scenarios Reconciled
Revenue risks & projections finalized
3
April 9
Final Committee Meeting
Security fee, preschool & revenue risks discussed
4
April 14
Board Presentation
Finance Committee presents the balanced budget
5
May 19 TODAY
Board Vote
Full Board formally adopts the FY2026/27 budget
2026 Finance Committee
  • Ellie Bahrmasel
  • David Rotenberg
  • Bruce Simonsformer Treasurer
  • Bram Spector
  • Jason Taylorformer Treasurer
  • Alan Tinsmonformer Treasurer
  • Irv Yoskowitz
Larry SchorTreasurer & Chair, Finance Comm.
Jan KaufmanExecutive Director
Eli FriedmanFinance Director
Dan LaytinPresident
Amanda GreeneSenior Rabbi
What ChangedApril Board Meeting  →  May Board Meeting
Updated May 19, 2026

Changes from the April board presentation to the May board presentation.

Item April May
P & L
Foundation Distribution
4% of rolling 3-yr average
$250,000 $269,716
Administration Expense (health insurance premiums lower than projected) $1,303,015 $1,255,187
Total Revenue $3,463,549 $3,483,265
Total Expenses $3,364,103 $3,316,275
Net Surplus +$99,446 +$166,990
Balance Sheet
★ NEW — Foundation Distribution
1% of rolling 3-yr average
Investment Account Restricted Building Fund
$0 $67,429
Finance Committee Recommendations
Updated May 19, 2026

Five recommendations require Board approval: dues levels, new fundraising goals, security fee structure, Investment Account policy, and formal budget review process.

📋 Member Dues — Raise 4%
  • Raise dues 4% for all membership levels
  • Top-tier donors (Sustainers/Patrons/Pillars) also increased 4% — a 10% increase yields only +$33K
  • Why it matters: Dues = 52% of income — our largest revenue source.
🎯 New Fundraising Goals
  • Building Fund: Launch a dedicated reserve for facility repairs. Most synagogues have one; Sinai currently does not.
  • Why it matters: Reduces pressure on existing budget lines and protects our Investment Account.
🛡 Security Fee — Fair Share Model
  • No household exempt.
  • Proposed tiers:
  • Individual: $300  ·  Family: $400  ·  Sus/Pat/Pil: $400
  • New HHD Appeal ($50K) focused on higher security costs.
  • Why it matters: Security is non-discretionary and costs keep rising.  
🏦 Ensuring Sinai's Future
  • Commitment to balanced annual operating budget
  • Investment Account
    • No drawdowns to “balance” budget
    • Reserved for building maintenance and capital repairs
  • Foundation
    • Annual distribution of 4% of rolling 3-yr average
      • 2026/2027 distribution: $269,716
    • ★ NEW 1% of portfolio value distributed to IA Building Fund
      • 2026/2027 distribution: $67,429
🗓 Budget Review — January/February 2027
  • Finance Committee review of YTD Budget
  • Board recommendations to maintain balanced budget
  • Why it matters: A mid-year checkpoint allows the board to course-correct before year-end.
What the Board Should Watch · Key Risks
Updated May 19, 2026

As board members, you have a fiduciary duty to understand these risks. The budget is balanced — but depends on several optimistic assumptions.

⚠️ Revenue May Fall Short
Annual Appeal ($220K) and Benefit ($180K) are optimistic. The Appeal came in $90K below goal this year. If both fall short, we face a $150K–$200K deficit. The new Development Director helps, but not immediately.
→ Ask management for a contingency plan if revenue falls short.
🏫 Preschool Enrollment is Unpredictable
Revenue depends on enrollment count, days, and hours. We operate in a competitive market and families often commit late. Target is break-even — but enrollment risk is real.
→ Request a preschool enrollment report before the May 12 vote.
🛡 Security Costs Keep Rising
Security is $282,472/year — non-discretionary. We cannot reduce guards without compromising safety. Costs have risen significantly and show no sign of stabilizing.
→ Approve the fair-share security fee model in principle today.
💊 Healthcare Costs
Healthcare costs are budgeted to decline for the first time in years, but will still need to be carefully monitored. Sinai covers an unusually high share of each employee's premium — a benefits policy review remains warranted.
→ Direct management to continue monitoring healthcare cost trends.
Finance Committee Recommends a Balanced Budget
Updated May 19, 2026

A balanced budget: revenue and expenses in balance, net surplus +$167K. Security Fee revenue increases to $195K under the new fair-share model.

FY 2026/2027 Proposed Budget
FY 2025/2026 Forecasted Actual
Total Revenue
$3.48M
FY 2026/27  (+$717K YoY)
Total Revenue
$2.77M
FY 2025/26 forecasted actual
Security Fee Revenue
$195K
Fair-share per-diem model
vs. Prior Year
+$72K
was $123K · new model FY26/27
Total Expenses
$3.32M
FY 2026/27 budget
YoY Expense Change
+$358K
vs. $2.96M last year
Net Surplus
+$167K
Budget is balanced ✓
YoY Net Swing
+$359K
from −$192K deficit last year

⚑  Revenue projections do not yet reflect the expected impact of our new Development Director.

Where Our Money Comes From · FY2026/27
Updated May 19, 2026

Revenue comes from 9 sources. Our two anchors — member dues (51%) and a confirmed anonymous gift — provide the base. The first annual distribution ($270K) from the Chicago Sinai Foundation is a key new revenue source.

Revenue SourceFY26/27Chg FY25/26Note
Member Dues$1,759K+$166K4% increase · 51% of total revenue
Security Fee$195K+$72KNew per-diem fee structure. See Security Fee slide for detail.
HHD Appeal$50K+$50KNew High Holiday fundraising appeal — open to members and non-members attending services.
Annual Appeal$220K+$26KOptimistic; assumes Dev Director impact
Benefit Event$180K+$20KNet proceeds from annual gala
Preschool Tuition$279K+$25KDifficult to predict — parents commit late
Religious School$180K+$38KOn track with projections
Foundation Distribution ★$270KNEWFoundation Board approved 4% drawdown policy. Annual distribution of 4% of rolling 3-yr average; 2026/2027 distribution approved at $269,716.
Anonymous Gift$350K+$50KConfirmed. Not guaranteed every year.
TOTAL REVENUE$3,483K+$717Kvs. $2,766K last year
Revenue by Source · FY25/26 vs. FY26/27
Updated May 19, 2026

FY25/26 Annualized  ·  FY26/27 Budget  ·  % = year-over-year change

FY25/26 Annualized
FY26/27 Budget
Member Dues
$1593K
$1759K (+10.4%)
Security Fee
$123K
$195K (+59.1%)
HHD Appeal
$50K (NEW)
Annual Appeal
$194K
$220K (+13.6%)
Benefit Event
$160K
$180K (+12.5%)
Preschool
$255K
$279K (+9.7%)
Religious School
$142K
$180K (+26.6%)
★ Foundation Dist.
$270K (NEW)
Anonymous Gift
$300K
$350K (+16.7%)

All values in USD · FY25/26 figures are annualized actuals

Where Our Money Goes · FY2026/27 Expenses
Updated May 19, 2026

84% of budget: Staff & Operations (38%), Clergy (23%), Occupancy (14%), Security (9%). All programs share the remaining 16%.

Spending AreaFY26/27%ChangeNote
Staff & Ops$1,255,18738%+$181KNew Dev Director, maintenance; health insurance premiums lower than projected
Clergy & Leadership$759,04823%+$52KLargely contractual — limited flexibility
Occupancy$457,54714%−$58KSecurity costs broken out from Occupancy; rent & utilities on plan
Security$282,4728%+$94KIncreased presence post-Michigan attack; higher hours & rates.
Preschool Program$263,7578%+$39KPaired with $279K tuition → nearly breaks even
Religious School$126,6364%+$6KOn plan; no changes recommended
High Holiday Program$91,2253%+$16KIncludes security; issues resolved
Community Programs$45,3001%+$35KIncrease is mostly reclassification, not new spend
Music$35,104<1%−$8KSlight decrease; issues resolved
TOTAL EXPENSES$3,316,275100%+$358Kvs. $2,958,391 last year
NET SURPLUS+$166,990Revenue exceeds expenses — budget is balanced ✓
Expenses by Area · FY25/26 vs. FY26/27
Updated May 19, 2026

FY25/26 Annualized  ·  FY26/27 Budget  ·  % = year-over-year change

FY25/26 Annualized
FY26/27 Budget
Staff & Operations
$1074K
$1255K (+16.9%)
Clergy & Leadership
$707K
$759K (+7.4%)
Occupancy
$459K
$458K (−0.4%)
Security
$191K
$282K (+47.8%)
Preschool Program
$224K
$264K (+17.6%)
Religious School
$121K
$127K (+4.8%)
High Holiday
$75K
$91K (+21.5%)
Community Programs
$10K
$45K (+336.8%)
Music
$43K
$35K (−17.7%)
CSCUpdated May 19, 2026
Path Forward
Together, we are building
a sustainable Sinai.
  • Balanced FY2026/27 budget with a +$166,990 projected surplus
  • Revenue growth driven by new sources — Foundation + anonymous gift and increase in Security Fee
  • Security not fully funded; equitable fair-share fee model in development with potential offset from HHD Appeal
  • Investment Account preserved; Foundation distributions begin this year
  • Revenue assumptions are optimistic — contingency planning is underway
  • Board vote: May 19, 2026